The Canine Conundrum: Weighing the Pros and Cons of Kibble

Black and Tan dog laying down next to a bowl of dry food
As a concerned dog owner, choosing the best diet for your four-legged companion is critical because it can significantly impact your dog’s overall health, well-being, and quality of life, positively or negatively. To understand the advantages and drawbacks of kibble, learn about the 5 pros and cons below.

Feeding Dogs Kibble: 5 Pros

  1. Convenience and Storage

The primary reason for kibble’s overall popularity lies in its convenience. Commercial kibble:

    • Is easy to store.
    • Has a longer shelf life (although not indefinite).
    • Does not require refrigeration like fresh or specialized diets.

These reasons make it a hassle-free option for busy dog owners. Additionally, kibble is simple to measure and dispense for precise portion control.

  1. Cost-Effective

Another benefit is kibble is usually more budget-friendly than other dog food options. Its mass production and longer shelf life contribute to lower costs. For owners on a tight budget, kibble may be the best option without breaking the bank.

  1. Nutrient Fortification
    Tan English Cocker Spaniel Laying on the Floor next to Food Bowl
    English Cocker Spaniel Lying on the Floor next to Food Bowl (Courtesy: Pixabay.com/Alkhaine)

    Reputable kibble brands often fortify their products with essential nutrients, ensuring your dog receives a well-rounded diet making it easier to feed.

  1. Variety and Availability

Today’s variety and accessibility of K9 kibble allows dog parents to choose formulations tailored to their dog’s specific needs for:

    • Allergies.
    • Sensitivities.
    • Specific dietary requirements.
  1. Stable Ingredients

Typically, kibble can be less prone to spoilage and contamination. During manufacturing, high-temperature processing helps kill bacteria, parasites, and food-borne illnesses.

 

 


Did you miss our last blog post? Click here for
“The Raw Truth: 5 Pros and Cons of Raw Feeding Your Dog.”


 

 

Feeding Dogs Kibble: 5 Cons

  1. Quality Issues

While many high-quality kibble options exist, there are also lower-quality products.

    • Budget-friendly kibbles may contain undesirable ingredients compromising the reactivity and value of nutrients. Ingredients including:
      • Fillers that are cheaper, less nutritious, and may cause issues.

        Chicken eating Feed Grade Food
        Hen Eating Feed-Grade Food (Courtesy: Pixabay.com/Andreas Gollner)
      • Artificial additives.
      • Lower-grade protein sources.
    • Kibble typically contains “feed-grade ingredients,” not human-grade offering less quality and nutrition.
    • The FDA allows pet food manufacturers to use diseased animals, meat byproducts, and meat sources from non-slaughtered animals (without telling you). (Source: RawBistro.com) Dog parents should thoroughly research kibble brands based on their dog’s needs, breed, age, and health issues.
  1. Processing and Additives
    • Most commercial kibble uses extrusion, a processing method involving high temperatures and pressure, which degrades the nutritional content from overprocessing. (Source: en.AllPetFood.net)
    • Carcinogens are also created when ingredients are highly processed. (Source: DogCancer.com)
    • Acrylamide, a chemical used in industrial processes can also be produced when vegetables, like potatoes, are heated to high temps in the presence of certain sugars. (Acrylamide is also found in cigarette smoke!) (Source: Cancer.gov)
    • Additionally, some kibble may contain additives that may not align with a dog’s optimal health or cause health issues or challenges. (Source: RawBistro.com) Additives like:
      • Artificial colors/dyes that can cause cancer and hypersensitivity.
      • Artificial flavors and enhancers.
      • Artificial preservatives.
      • Synthetic nutrients (including vitamins and minerals) to replace those lost during manufacturing.
  1. Hydration Challenges
    Light brown puppy laying on the green grass next to a metal water bowl
    Puppy Lying on the Grass Next to a Water Bowl (Courtesy: Pixabay.com/Iris Depiris)

    Unlike wet or raw food, kibble has a low moisture content. This can be a drawback for dogs who don’t drink enough water, potentially leading to dehydration. Adequate hydration is vital for a dog’s overall health. Owners need to be mindful of their dog’s daily water intake when feeding kibble, particularly with urinary or kidney disease. (Source: PetMD.com/DogNutritionCenter)

  1. Potential Allergens

Some dogs may develop allergies or sensitivities to certain ingredients commonly found in kibble, such as grains or specific proteins. Identifying and addressing these allergens can often be challenging, requiring a slow process of elimination and potential dietary changes. (Source: JustFoodForDogs.com)

  1. Digestibility Concerns

While many dogs can digest kibble without issues, some may experience difficulty breaking down the dry pellets. This can be particularly problematic for:

    • Dogs with dental problems.
    • Older dogs with reduced chewing ability.
    • Dogs that quickly gobble down their food. In such cases, wet or softer food options might be more suitable.

 

The Final Word

Dante, a black Cane Corso, eating his dinner out of a raised food bowl
Our Black Cane Corso, Dante, Enjoying his Dinner (Courtesy: DaBoyzCaneCorso.com)
  • Your decision about feeding kibble involves weighing the pros and cons along with your:
    • Dog’s specific needs.
    • Your personal preferences.
    • Your budget.
  • Prioritize the quality of any kibble to ensure it meets your dog’s nutritional and energy requirements (especially for active, working dogs).
  • Remain mindful as dry dog food can also:
    • Carry a risk for bacteria and mycotoxins.
    • Contain storage mites causing unwanted medical issues.
    • Cause the fats in (and sprayed on) the food to become rancid after the bag is opened.
  • Along with your vet, always monitor your furry friend’s overall health, hydration, and energy with a kibble diet and make adjustments, if necessary.

Remember, a happy and healthy dog is the result of a well-balanced, high-quality diet (just like their humans), regular veterinary care, and daily exercise mixed with lots of love and attention!

Even if you decide to feed your dog kibble, there are many ways to
make it healthier with fresh, whole foods. Watch for our
next – and final – series post for easy tips and tricks.

 


Da Boyz Cane Corso Logo Showing Bubba and Dante
Da Boyz Cane Corso Logo of Bubba & Dante

Keep Following our Bi-Monthly Posts to Learn How to do the BEST for your dog!

 

Subscribe or bookmark our site to be notified of new content!

 

Questions? Reach out to us at Info@DaBoyzCaneCorso.com!

 


 

Share the Post:

Related Posts